Unique among Edgartown hotels, The Sydney features 22 chic guestrooms. Our four Edgartown hotels each offer something for everyone, whether you’re a lover of Martha’s Vineyard history, or prefer the newest boutique hotel rooms on the island. Our original Captain’s House offers 8 unique, historic guestrooms in a magnificent Victorian home built in 1892 by whaling captain Charles William Fisher and feature lovingly preserved architectural features. Our new building adjacent to the Captain’s House is Edgartown’s newest hotel construction, and features 14 beautifully designed new guest accommodations.